
J K Rowling
747532699
First Published in 1997
I'm going to say something right now, just for the sake of full disclosure. I'm a huge Harry Potter fan. I was one of those people who was in line at midnight waiting for the seventh book to come out. So when I decided to reread all seven of the books for the purposes of this blog I knew I would have a hard time reading them as "literature" rather than as the most fun ever. I was especially afraid of finding flaws since they may make me love it less and that would be terrible.
Having said this, I'll forgive you for thinking I'm biased and completely unreliable when I assert that this book stands up to scrutiny. It's not perfect but it is damn good, or at least good enough that I don't have to be ashamed of liking it.
This is a work both of children's literature and of fantasy, so it comes as no great surprise that it's escapist. Harry is neglected and abused by his aunt and uncle, but then he finds out that he's actually a wizard and that he saved the world hen he was a year old. It's all a little much to believe. You kind of have to wonder that Harry does, even if he's only eleven. Of course, the Magical World is hardly perfect, there are many scary, dark places, but that darkness is only really hinted at in this volume. That being said, the short image in the Forbidden Forest of Quirrell/Voldemort with unicorn blood dripping from his mouth still sends more chills down my back than any other in the whole series.
The plot structure is an old one, but I think it's used effectively. The character goes through the story completely mistaken about what's going on. All is revealed at the end by the bad guy, who's gloating seconds before our hero clobbers him. But really, Harry never really clobbers anyone, ever. He's just an ordinary kid who gets mixed up in craziness, I think that's what sets Harry Potter apart from the average boy-adventure novel.
This is the first time in a while that I reread The Philosopher's Stone and it surprised me how fast paced it was. Old JK has become rather notorious for her huge volumes but this book is barely 200 pages and it's almost all action. That may be just because Harry's so young so the angst just isn't there yet. One interesting matter of technique I noticed was that there was often no break in between scenes, the narrative just went on, even though there was a considerable change in time and/or place. This, of course, adds to the fast paced feel.
It's difficult to say how well this novel stands on it's own, since the whole Harry Potter universe is so much a part of my consciousness, but I will say it all seems a little thin with out that which came after it and the sense of danger just isn't there. Everything just happens too quickly for it to develop.
I love the first chapter, it has this atmosphere of something great and urgent. But it belongs to the series, not to the book, in fact you can't really understand all that's going on until the sixth book at least.
But I still love this book and if you don't your opinion doesn't matter, so there.
No comments:
Post a Comment