Wednesday, August 27, 2008

The White Tiger



Aravind Adiga
1416562591
2008

I think I've learned not to read anyone else's book reviews before completing my own. A lot of people in the literary blogosphere did not like this book at all, to the extent that they're surprise it was even considered for publication.
I certainly didn't hate it nearly that much but I am having some trouble forming a coherent opinion on it. I guess it was okay. I don't know.
The novel is in the form of seven letter written to the Premiere of China just before a visit to India. They are written by Balram, a self-described "entrepreneur". Balram tells the story of how he rose from a simple Bihari village boy to the owner of a large taxi service in Bangalore. Needless to say, it involves a lot of murder, bribery and Ukrainian prostitutes.
The onesided nature of the epistolary structure leads me to necessarily compare this book to last year's The Reluctant Fundamentalist. In this books favour, I have to say that the narrator's dialogue wasn't nearly as annoying as it sometimes was in that book, and the exposition was much more natural.
Balram himself is, at least to me, almost entirely unsympathetic. I sometimes wonder if he's actually telling the truth. I assume this was intentional and he's suppose to be an anti-hero, or something. (Come to think of it, why would a wanted criminal risk exposing himself by writing a letter to a forign leader? That's quite a plot hole.) Balram has a disdain for all institutions which is understandable given his lifetime of watching them not work, but his enthusiastic embracing of corruption doesn't really make me like him more. I was unconvinced by his assertion that this was his only way out. And I was slightly confused by his chicken coop metaphor.
I don't really have much else to say about this book. I guess that means that it wasn't so good afterall.

Tuesday, August 19, 2008

A Short History of Tractors in Ukranian



Marina Lewycka
1594200440
2005

I really enjoyed this book. Even before I had completly finished it I was already recommending it to all my friends. Especially the Ukranian ones.
On the surface, this book is about a bad marriage. Specifically, about the marriage of Nikolai, an 84 year old Ukrainan widower who escaped to Britan after the second world war and a thirty six year old gold-digger recent arrival named Valentina. Nikolai's two grown daughters try to put aside their many silly feuds to help their father get out of his predicement. Interlaced with all this are excerpts from a history of the tractor that Nikolai is writing and a history of the family before they emmigrated to Britan, as know by Nadezhda, the younger of the two daughters.
Nadezhda and her older sister, Vera, are ten years appart. This means that Vera was born in the thirties and lived through the war, while Nadezhda was only born after the family had fled Europe. This is the reason for the differences between them. Vera is a cynic and unmerciful in her opinions but Nadezhda always assumes everyone has good intentions, even Valentina, at least at the beginning.
If ten years constitues a generation gap, the fifty years between husband and wife is a far bigger one. Nikolai, and the Ukranians of his generation, is like a tractor. He's not very good looking or glamourous, but he can take his knocks. He's a survivor. Valentina, and the new Ukraine, is like a rusting Rolls-Royce that won't even run. All show, no substance.
This book is not just bashing post-Soviet society, because it doesn't seem to like Soviet or pre-Soviet society either. It's about the inability of different generations to understand each others point of view and the importance of the past in shaping who we are.
I loved it. I laughed, I cried. You should read it.

Friday, August 8, 2008

Consolation



Michael Redhill
9780385659512
2006

One of the consequences of living in the New World is that your sense of time is a bit off. I'm quite sure my great-aunt hen house in Poland is older than any of the buildings in Toronto but no one would cry if they tried to tear it down. However, there is something to the notion of going back to the beginning of a place, even if that beginning was only a hundred and fifty years ago.
The main plot of Consolation is the dying Historian David Hollis's attempts to "raise awareness" I guess you could say, of the history of his hometown of Toronto by showing that it is sill present.
There's more playing around with time lines. There are two main plot lines. The First is about David's widow's efforts to prove his semi-crackpot theories about there being a set of photographic negatives from the early years of Toronto in the hold of a ship that is buried under the ground at the site of a new stadium.
The second plot line is about the man who made those photographs. He's Jem Hallam, a failed Apothecary who accidentally ended up in the photography business along with a dying Irishman and a young widow.
The parallels between the present and past story lines are interesting. Both are about the process of mourning the loss of loved ones, either by death or by physical separation. There is also this subtext that I, as a lifelong history buff, find fascinating; the idea of history as a form mourning, a desperate grasping for a connection to people long dead. I'm not sure what that makes people who literally pour concrete on the past though. However there's also this whole idea about how people in the past suffered to build up the things we took for granted, which strays dangerously into good-old-days territory.
Structurally, the book is divided into five section, two of which take place in the past and three that take place in the present. The past sections are nice and linear but the present sections jump around between the time before David dies and the time at which is wife is holding a vigil at the construction site. This wouldn't really be a problem except that each section is labeled with a date to begin with and straying from it seems a bit like cheating to me.
Also great was all the little titbits of information I learned about my home town. I actually didn't know that everything south of Front Street was landfill. although it would explain the smell. Also good was that, since this is a book about Toronto that actually got international attention, the public library had about 2000 copies (not an exaggeration) and I didn't even have to go on a waiting list.

Wednesday, July 30, 2008

Long Term Project: 40 Years of Booker Winners

I'm attempting to, some time before I die, catch up to everyone else and read all of those books that won the Booker Prize before I was born. I'm going to use this post as a list and handy referance. All the books that are already reviewed are linked and highlighted.

1969 Something to Answer For by P H Newby
1970 The Elected Member by Bernice Rubens
1971 In a Free State by V S Naipaul
1972 G by John Berger
1973 The Siege of Krishnapur by J G Farrell
1974 The Conservationist by Nadine Gordimer
1974 Holiday by Stanley Middleton
1975 Heat and Dust by Ruth Prawer Jhabvala
1976 Saville by David Storey
1977 Staying On by Paul Scott
1978 The Sea, the Sea by Iris Murdoch
1979 Offshore by Penelope Fitzgerald
1980 Rites of Passage by William Golding
1981 Midnight's Children by Salman Rushdie
1982 Schindler's Ark by Thomas Keneally
1983 Life & Times of Michael K by J M Coetzee
1984 Hotel du Lac by Anita Brookner
1985 The Bone People by Kerl Hulme
1986 The Old Devils by Kingsley Amis
1987 Moon Tiger by Penelope Livley
1988 Oscar and Lucinda by Peter Carey
1989 The Remains of the Day by Kazuo Ishiguro
1990 Possession by A S Byatt
1991 The Famished Road by Ben Okri
1992 The English Patient by Michael Ondaatje
1992 Sacred Hunger by Barry Unsworth
1993 Patty Clarke Ha Ha Ha by Roddy Doyle
1994 How Late It Was, How Late by James Kelman
1995 The Gohst Road by Pat Barker
1996 Last Orders by Graham Swift
1997 The God of Small Things by Arundhati Roy
1998 Amsterdam by Ian McEwan
1999 Disgrace by J M Coetzee
2000 The Blind Assassin by Margret Atwood
2001 True History of the Kelly Gang by Peter Carey
2002 The Life of Pi by Yann Martel
2003 Vernon God Little by DBC Pierre
2004 The Line of Beauty by Allan Hollinghurst
2005 The Sea by John Banville
2006 The Inheritance of Loss by Kiran Desai
2007 The Gathering by Anne Enright
2008 The White Tiger by Aravind Adiga

Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Stone



J K Rowling
747532699
First Published in 1997

I'm going to say something right now, just for the sake of full disclosure. I'm a huge Harry Potter fan. I was one of those people who was in line at midnight waiting for the seventh book to come out. So when I decided to reread all seven of the books for the purposes of this blog I knew I would have a hard time reading them as "literature" rather than as the most fun ever. I was especially afraid of finding flaws since they may make me love it less and that would be terrible.

Having said this, I'll forgive you for thinking I'm biased and completely unreliable when I assert that this book stands up to scrutiny. It's not perfect but it is damn good, or at least good enough that I don't have to be ashamed of liking it.

This is a work both of children's literature and of fantasy, so it comes as no great surprise that it's escapist. Harry is neglected and abused by his aunt and uncle, but then he finds out that he's actually a wizard and that he saved the world hen he was a year old. It's all a little much to believe. You kind of have to wonder that Harry does, even if he's only eleven. Of course, the Magical World is hardly perfect, there are many scary, dark places, but that darkness is only really hinted at in this volume. That being said, the short image in the Forbidden Forest of Quirrell/Voldemort with unicorn blood dripping from his mouth still sends more chills down my back than any other in the whole series.

The plot structure is an old one, but I think it's used effectively. The character goes through the story completely mistaken about what's going on. All is revealed at the end by the bad guy, who's gloating seconds before our hero clobbers him. But really, Harry never really clobbers anyone, ever. He's just an ordinary kid who gets mixed up in craziness, I think that's what sets Harry Potter apart from the average boy-adventure novel.

This is the first time in a while that I reread The Philosopher's Stone and it surprised me how fast paced it was. Old JK has become rather notorious for her huge volumes but this book is barely 200 pages and it's almost all action. That may be just because Harry's so young so the angst just isn't there yet. One interesting matter of technique I noticed was that there was often no break in between scenes, the narrative just went on, even though there was a considerable change in time and/or place. This, of course, adds to the fast paced feel.

It's difficult to say how well this novel stands on it's own, since the whole Harry Potter universe is so much a part of my consciousness, but I will say it all seems a little thin with out that which came after it and the sense of danger just isn't there. Everything just happens too quickly for it to develop.

I love the first chapter, it has this atmosphere of something great and urgent. But it belongs to the series, not to the book, in fact you can't really understand all that's going on until the sixth book at least.

But I still love this book and if you don't your opinion doesn't matter, so there.

Monday, July 28, 2008

Last Orders



Graham Swift
0679308571

Back in high school, we read King Lear in my OAC English class. My overall impression was "I don't get it". But my teacher said that was okay, you need to be old to get it. Well this book is also about being old and complaining about your kids, but this time I think I may get it.

Last Order is about some old war buddies who didn't die in the war. Now one of them, Jack, has died and they take a road trip to Margate, on the coast of Kent, to scatter his ashes, like he asked along with Jack adopted son Vince.

I think the fact that they didn't die in the war is significant. Death in war is even more a matter of chance than death under other circumstances. Chance in life is a matter on the minds of many of the characters, as symbolized by Ray's passion for betting on horse races. They are obsessed with what it would be like if things were different. They are unhappy, with their careers, their marriages the way they raised their children. Jack things he should have been a doctor, Ray wishes he had met Amy first and Amy imagines, with guilt, what her life would be like if June were never born. Vince is glad he didn't become a butcher like the old man but you get the sense that he know how shallow he is.

The structure of the book is interesting. Each section is labeled either with the character is provides the narrative for that section of buy the location of the guys on their road trip. At first I was confused about who was speaking in the location sections, but then I realised it was always Ray. The character talk about Jack, their lives and their child, who none of them seem to have a good relationship with. They are physically or emotionally distant from their children, often both.

This is another example of contemporary literature's fondness for non-linear time lines, although strictly speaking they're not so much jumping around in time as "remembering". You can tell because the present-day parts are in present tense and the remembered bits are in past tense.

I like the title because there are at least two ways you can read it. The first is that it refers to the last orders than come before a bar closes. It's at the end of the night just like the character are at the end of their lives. This little trip is like their last drink. The second is the military reading. It was Jack's last order to his friends, his fellow soldiers.

Tender is the Night



F. Scott Fitzgerald

It seems that every contemporary novel has what can be called a loose relationship with time. Random time jumps or two more or less equal narratives in different time lines are very popular devices. This book was one of the first to tell a story out of order.

There are three parts. The first part is the middle, the second part is the beginning and part of the middle and the last part is the end.

The first part is interesting because it is almost misleading. Unlike the other two parts it is told form the point of view of an outsider who gives us a skewed picture of the main characters.

Those main characters are a married couple called Dick and Nicole Diver, expat Americans who are living in the south of France. Rosemary Hoyt, a young Hollywood starlette, arrives there on vacation and, in her own words, falls in love with them. She is, I suppose, a femme fatale, because her mutual physical attraction with Dick is a signpost for the end of the Drivers' marriage, but she herself is so wide-eyed and childlike that the label seems slightly ridiculous. Part One ends with Rosemary's "revelation" about Nicole's mental illness.

At the beginning of Part Two we take a trip to the end of the First World War. Dick is a young psychiatrist still in the army and Nicole is a patient with schizophrenia at a Swiss sanitarium.. It tells about their courtship/Nicole's recovery, because they're really the same thing. Then we jump to directly after Part One. Dick has opened up his own hospital with one of his colleagues. He feels trapped in his marriage so he goes on a long trip by himself and ends up in a fight with the police in Rome.

Part Two is about what's wrong with Dick and Nicole and with their marriage. In a very significant way, Nicole will always be a patient to Dick and he will always be her doctor.

Part Three is inevitable after the things that came before it. Dick and Nicole's marriage is disintegrating but it will have a long death. So there's lots of wandering around Europe and drinking too much. The interesting thing is that while Dick seems to be sinking deeper and deeper into depression and alcoholism Nicole seems to be actually recovering; or at the very least, she doesn't need Dick anymore. She asserts her independence by having an affair with a man she cares nothing about. They get divorced with hardly a whimper and Dick moves to upstate New York and all the boredom and obscurity that that implies.

The structure is very effective at reflecting the mood of pointless time wasting affluence. There's no direction so why should there be linearity? This is a great book, and it would be only for technical reason.

However it great for more than that. It's one of those books you can read the entire humans condition into if you work hard enough. There's so much I left out of my whirlwind summary; Money and Independence, Americans and the American Dream (it's Fitzgerald, you know the American Dream will figure in at some point) illusions and the movies, Daddy issues and that whole thing with Abe North and the Negros that I really don't understand. I imagine this is a book that is meant to be reread.